Culture Matters with Bad News! A Large-Scale Study of Media Coverage after Startup Failure

Conference Paper
Academy of Management Proceedings 2024(1), 18562
Authors

Oliver Mork

Christoph Ihl

Published

January 1, 2024

Doi

10.5465/AMPROC.2024.18562abstract

Abstract
Given that mass media can confer organizational legitimacy and act as an information intermediary between startups and relevant stakeholders, we examine the process of establishing legitimacy and the response to failure across different cultural settings. Employing state-of-the-art natural language processing models, we extract sentiments from a sample of 2,041,607 sentences covering 67,306 startups from the United States, the United Kingdom, and Germany. Utilizing robust econometric methods, we reveal pronounced cultural differences in the character of media coverage for both operating and closed startups. Specifically, German media tends to portray domestic startups less positively, while the United States exhibits the most positive coverage, with the United Kingdom falling in between. Notably, our findings include a positive in-group bias solely for operating startups in the United States, while Germany displays a negative in-group bias for both operating and closed startups. Our study underscores the role of national culture, the importance of comparative entrepreneurship research, and the heterogeneous nature of entrepreneurial phenomena among different cultures.

Research

© Anne Gärtner

  • Conference Paper
  • 2024
  • Vol. 2024(1)
  • DOI

Authors

Oliver Mork, Christoph Ihl

Abstract

Given that mass media can confer organizational legitimacy and act as an information intermediary between startups and relevant stakeholders, we examine the process of establishing legitimacy and the response to failure across different cultural settings. Employing state-of-the-art natural language processing models, we extract sentiments from a sample of 2,041,607 sentences covering 67,306 startups from the United States, the United Kingdom, and Germany. Utilizing robust econometric methods, we reveal pronounced cultural differences in the character of media coverage for both operating and closed startups. Specifically, German media tends to portray domestic startups less positively, while the United States exhibits the most positive coverage, with the United Kingdom falling in between. Notably, our findings include a positive in-group bias solely for operating startups in the United States, while Germany displays a negative in-group bias for both operating and closed startups. Our study underscores the role of national culture, the importance of comparative entrepreneurship research, and the heterogeneous nature of entrepreneurial phenomena among different cultures.

Tags

Startup Failure Media Coverage Culture